M HYPE SPLASH
// general

Double Complement of a set proof

By Emma Valentine
$\begingroup$

Question states:

Prove the law of double complements for sets:

If $A$ is a set and $A^\complement$ is its complement than prove that:

$$ (A^\complement)^\complement = A$$

I started with:

$$ A^\complement = U - A$$ where U is the universal set.

But I do not understand how to go further.

$\endgroup$ 0

3 Answers

$\begingroup$

Let $A$ be a subset of some universe $U$.

We'll prove this by proving that the two sets are subsets of each other (and must therefore be equal). We'll use nothing but the definition that if $x \in X$, then $x \notin X^C$ (and what clearly follows: if $x \notin X$, then $x \in X^C$).

Take $a \in A$. Then $a \notin A^C$. Then $a \in (A^C)^C$, by definition of the complement. So $A \subseteq (A^C)^C$.

Now take $a \in (A^C)^C$. That means $a \notin A^C$. Therefore $a \in A$. So $(A^C)^C \subseteq A$.

As $A \subseteq (A^C)^C$ and $(A^C)^C \subseteq A$, we conclude that $A = (A^C)^C$.

For other techniques, see here. This is, in some sense, a duplicate question.

$\endgroup$ $\begingroup$

I know it's old, but here's how I solved it using logical equivalences. For people who coming from the future, I was required to solve it like this.

We know that: $A=\{x|x\in A\}$, which reads: there is an x in the set of A. And we know that the complement of A is $A^c=\{x| x\notin A\}$, which reads: there is an x which is not in A.

We start with $(A^c)^c = \{x|x\notin A^c\}$ is read as: there is an x that is not in the complement set of A. That means that if an x is not in the complement set of A (and the complement set of A is the set that doesn't have A), then it must be in A. All we do is use negation rules.

$(A^c)^c = \{x|x\notin A^c\}$

$(A^c)^c = \{x|\neg (x \in A^c)\}$

$(A^c)^c = \{x|\neg (x \notin A)\}$

$(A^c)^c = \{x|\neg (\neg (x \in A))\}$

$(A^c)^c = \{x| x \in A\}$

Therefore

$(A^c)^c=A$

$\endgroup$ $\begingroup$

I am not completely sure of how valid my proof is, but i'd like to share it, if someone would like to tell me what's wrong about the proof.

$A^C = U - A$

$(A^C)^C = U - (A^C)$

And now substituting the first statement.

$(A^C)^C = U - (U - A)$

$(A^C)^C = U - U + A = A$

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

Sign up or log in

Sign up using Google Sign up using Facebook Sign up using Email and Password

Post as a guest

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy